Fri Feb 21 17:43:00 GMT 2003
I haven't yet imported the MacOSX fix into my tree, though I plan to do so soon.
I'm hoping to have a bit of time to look at this again starting on Tuesday.
If the gcc3.3 release is still on schedule, I agree that doing a full import would be risky. We should definitely do it for the trunk, though perhaps after the official 6.2 GC release.
Should I try to extract and check in the dl_iterate_phdr() fix separately? That's still somewhat risky, since the fix affects several files. But it fixes a serious bug in the 3.3 libgcj, which I would really like to see fixed. (Or is there a plan to change dl_iterate_phdr to avoid the lock?) If we go this route, it would be nice if someone could check the MacOSX fix in separately as well.
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Andreas Tobler [mailto:firstname.lastname@example.org]
> Sent: Thursday, February 20, 2003 9:48 PM
> To: email@example.com
> Cc: Boehm, Hans; Andrew Haley; firstname.lastname@example.org
> Subject: Re: MacOSX support
> Tom Tromey wrote:
> >>>>>>"Andreas" == Andreas Tobler <email@example.com> writes:
> > Andreas> No, here on my testfloor it is more or less stable. The
> > Andreas> reason is, the patches will probably not be included in the
> > Andreas> actual boehm-gc in gcc. Hans stated that he'd like
> to import
> > Andreas> one of the recent snapshots into gcc by beginning of march.
> > Are your patches in Hans' release? If not, we'll need your
> patches if
> > we want this work to appear in 3.3. Even if so, we might still need
> > them, depending on whether I can to do the import.
> I don't know the status yet. I just took the patches from gc mailing
> list, which are for a 6.2alpha release and adapted them to current
> boehm-gc from gcc-cvs.
> The patches are not from my side, mainly from Jesse & Jeff.
> I can prepare something if the boehm-gc import will not happen before
> 3.3 release. On the other side, I'd like to see some more
> testing on it.
> I had severe problems which are not clear to me why.
> (reinstallation helped)
> What do you mean, and do you really plan to import boehm-gc soon, I
> mean before 3.3 release? If so, and the 3.3 release will
> happen soon, I
> feel a bit weak since this a new release of boehm-gc.
> Personaly I would
> deny such an import on projects of mine being short before release.
> Without heavy testing. If doing so I fear some support issues
> back. But that's my feeling. You probably have more experience in.
> So have to rebuild branch since I shot the source tree :)
More information about the Java