RMI Netwoek Overhead

[Per Arneng]

Hi!

We are making a master thesis and in that we are comparing overhead sizes on 
method calls
using RMI,RMI-IIOP, CORBA, DCOM and .Net Remoting. In our tests we have found 
that RMI generates the second largest amount of network traffic after .NET 
Remoting with SOAP on a single method call with a byte as parameter.
It uses almost  three times the amount as .NET Remoting in binary mode. Can 
someone explain why it is like this.

API 	             Byte 	Int 	Long 	Double
------------------------------------------------------
RMI 	   	      852    855  859 	        859
RMI-IIOP 	437 	432 	444 	444
Remoting TCP 	299 	301 	306 	308
Remoting HTTP 	1722 	1717 	1722 	1732
CORBA 		497 	500 	504 	504
DCOM TCP 		
DCOM UDP 	

We have found that when sending primitive data type arrays as parameters the 
network traffic is not
linear. Is there some optimization on primitive data type arrays in different 
sizes?

Thanks in advance!  Im not on the mailing list so please reply to my mail 
adress.

Best regards
   Per Arneng
-------------- next part --------------
Hi!

We are making a master thesis and in that we are comparing overhead sizes on method calls
using RMI,RMI-IIOP, CORBA, DCOM and .Net Remoting. In our tests we have found that RMI generates the second largest amount of network traffic after .NET Remoting with SOAP on a single method call with a byte as parameter.
It uses almost  three times the amount as .NET Remoting in binary mode. Can someone explain why it is like this.

API 	        Byte 	Int 	Long 	Double
RMI 	   	852 	855 	859 	859
RMI-IIOP 	437 	432 	444 	444
Remoting TCP 	299 	301 	306 	308
Remoting HTTP 	1722 	1717 	1722 	1732
CORBA 		497 	500 	504 	504
DCOM TCP 		
DCOM UDP 	
	
	
	

We have found that when sending primitive data type arrays as parameters the network traffic is not
linear. Is there some optimization on primitive data type arrays in different sizes?

Thanks in advance!  Im not on the mailing list so please reply to my mail adress.

Best regards
   Per Arneng