another compiler better than gcj ?

Martin Kahlert martin.kahlert@infineon.com
Sun Oct 21 23:49:00 GMT 2001


On Sun, Oct 21, 2001 at 06:56:16PM +1300, Bryce McKinlay wrote:
> It [Manta] seemed to have no problem compiling any of the java source I threw at 
> it, though it did seem to have an annoying habit of trying to parse 
> random .java files from the current directory/classpath, and error 
> messages seemed non-intuitive.

Hi Bryce,
i threw some of my old gcj problem code selection at it:

The first one gave a wrong answer:
class C {}
class D extends C implements I {}
interface I {}
interface J extends I {}

public class Class_1
{
  static void printIsAssignableFrom(Class a, Class b, boolean c)
    {
      // The field 'c' can be viewed to see the expected value.
      System.out.print(a.isAssignableFrom(b));
      System.out.print("    ");
      System.out.println(c);
    }

  public static void main (String arg[])
  {
    printIsAssignableFrom(I.class, J.class, true);
  }

$ ../Manta/build/mantac -o a Class_1.java
$ ./a
false    true


The second error comes from that code:
public class priv
{
 private class InnerPriv
    {
     private InnerPriv() { }
    }

 public void f()
    {
     InnerPriv ip = new InnerPriv();
    }

 public static void main(String[] args)
    {
     System.out.println( "Hello World" );
    }
}

$ ../Manta/build/mantac -o a priv.java
/sw/local_l/kahlert/Hello/priv.java:10: calling private constructor \
  in 'new InnerPriv'
...skipping link phase because of previous errors.

Since this is used in my big app, i did not try to compile that.
Otherwise it looks quite promising.

Regards
Martin.

-- 
The early bird catches the worm. If you want something else for       
breakfast, get up later.



More information about the Java mailing list