Reduce inline limits a bit to compensate changes in inlining metrics

Tue Feb 13 18:09:00 GMT 2018

> Hi.
> 
> I see quite SPEC 2006 benchmark changes for -Ofast -march=native:
> (note that size changes are not presented all)

Thanks! It is interesting that I do not see similar observations on Czerny which also
runs spec2006. In partiuclar both AMD machines agrees on soplex milc and bwaves.
They are flat in Czerny graph, so it may be again dependency of AMD machines on code lyaout
we was seeing recently.
https://gcc.opensuse.org/gcc-old/SPEC/CFP/sb-czerny-head-64-2006/410_bwaves_recent_big.png
https://gcc.opensuse.org/gcc-old/SPEC/CFP/sb-czerny-head-64-2006/433_milc_recent_big.png
https://gcc.opensuse.org/gcc-old/SPEC/CFP/sb-czerny-head-64-2006/450_soplex_recent_big.png

We sould take a look at spoplex. Megrez will pick up the patch tonight so we will see if the
regression reproduces on both bulldozer machines.

Honza

> 
> 1) gillan (AMD bulldozer):
> 
> +------------------------------------------+-------+----------+----------+---+-------+-------+
> | Performance Regressions - Execution Time |   Î”   | Previous | Current  | Ïƒ | Î” (B) | Ïƒ (B) |
> +------------------------------------------+-------+----------+----------+---+-------+-------+
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/453.povray              | 6.06% | 180.9933 | 191.9582 | - | 3.48% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/410.bwaves              | 5.13% | 307.0029 | 322.7495 | - | 8.11% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/433.milc                | 4.80% | 310.4705 | 325.3810 | - | 4.01% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/450.soplex              | 3.50% | 449.4463 | 465.1627 | - | 3.09% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/471.omnetpp            | 1.41% | 562.2769 | 570.1829 | - | 1.65% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/447.dealII              | 1.40% | 359.1753 | 364.1933 | - | 1.66% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/483.xalancbmk          | 1.00% | 430.9722 | 435.2821 | - | 7.59% |     - |
> +------------------------------------------+-------+----------+----------+---+-------+-------+
> 
> +-------------------------------------------+--------+----------+----------+---+--------+-------+
> | Performance Improvements - Execution Time |   Î”    | Previous | Current  | Ïƒ | Î” (B)  | Ïƒ (B) |
> +-------------------------------------------+--------+----------+----------+---+--------+-------+
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/429.mcf                 | -7.93% | 606.7478 | 558.6419 | - | -7.42% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/473.astar               | -2.07% | 577.5786 | 565.6328 | - | -6.16% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/435.gromacs              | -2.01% | 329.9626 | 323.3386 | - | -0.34% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/458.sjeng               | -1.71% | 667.0133 | 655.5964 | - | -1.54% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/436.cactusADM            | -1.07% | 379.5225 | 375.4560 | - | -4.12% |     - |
> +-------------------------------------------+--------+----------+----------+---+--------+-------+
> 
> +---------------------------------------------------+---------+--------------+--------------+---+---------+-------+
> |          Performance Improvements - size          |    Î”    |   Previous   |   Current    | Ïƒ |  Î” (B)  | Ïƒ (B) |
> +---------------------------------------------------+---------+--------------+--------------+---+---------+-------+
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/482.sphinx3/elf/sections/text    | -15.92% |  244450.0000 |  205522.0000 | - | -9.45%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/482.sphinx3/elf                  | -12.16% |  335640.0000 |  294816.0000 | - | -6.46%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/456.hmmer/elf/sections/text     | -12.14% |  395778.0000 |  347746.0000 | - | -9.75%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/483.xalancbmk/elf/sections/text | -10.43% | 3282082.0000 | 2939698.0000 | - | -11.33% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/453.povray/elf/sections/text     | -9.48%  | 1004658.0000 |  909426.0000 | - | -12.68% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/400.perlbench/elf/sections/text | -9.42%  | 1141458.0000 | 1033890.0000 | - | -9.75%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/456.hmmer/elf                   | -8.77%  |  508624.0000 |  464024.0000 | - | -7.28%  |     - |
> +---------------------------------------------------+---------+--------------+--------------+---+---------+-------+
> 
> 2) AMD Ryzen 5 machine:
> 
> +------------------------------------------+-------+----------+----------+---+-------+-------+
> | Performance Regressions - Execution Time |   Î”   | Previous | Current  | Ïƒ | Î” (B) | Ïƒ (B) |
> +------------------------------------------+-------+----------+----------+---+-------+-------+
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/450.soplex              | 6.28% | 204.6552 | 217.5132 | - | 8.06% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/433.milc                | 6.11% | 200.5912 | 212.8397 | - | 5.81% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/410.bwaves              | 3.28% | 145.9785 | 150.7609 | - | 5.37% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/462.libquantum         | 1.98% | 306.7858 | 312.8472 | - | 2.14% |     - |
> +------------------------------------------+-------+----------+----------+---+-------+-------+
> 
> +-------------------------------------------+--------+----------+----------+---+--------+-------+
> | Performance Improvements - Execution Time |   Î”    | Previous | Current  | Ïƒ | Î” (B)  | Ïƒ (B) |
> +-------------------------------------------+--------+----------+----------+---+--------+-------+
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/429.mcf                 | -4.71% | 255.8058 | 243.7667 | - | -1.18% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/473.astar               | -3.33% | 361.8033 | 349.7520 | - | 0.67%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/482.sphinx3              | -1.28% | 301.7175 | 297.8409 | - | 5.49%  |     - |
> +-------------------------------------------+--------+----------+----------+---+--------+-------+
> 
> +---------------------------------------------------+---------+--------------+--------------+---+---------+-------+
> |          Performance Improvements - size          |    Î”    |   Previous   |   Current    | Ïƒ |  Î” (B)  | Ïƒ (B) |
> +---------------------------------------------------+---------+--------------+--------------+---+---------+-------+
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/482.sphinx3/elf/sections/text    | -17.60% |  202370.0000 |  166754.0000 | - | -9.65%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/482.sphinx3/elf                  | -12.67% |  290680.0000 |  253856.0000 | - | -7.42%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/456.hmmer/elf/sections/text     | -10.58% |  340802.0000 |  304754.0000 | - | -7.92%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/400.perlbench/elf/sections/text | -9.50%  | 1166962.0000 | 1056066.0000 | - | -9.89%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/FP/453.povray/elf/sections/text     | -9.48%  |  993042.0000 |  898882.0000 | - | -13.33% |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/483.xalancbmk/elf/sections/text | -9.13%  | 3225538.0000 | 2931026.0000 | - | -9.93%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/456.hmmer/elf                   | -8.01%  |  455472.0000 |  418968.0000 | - | -5.44%  |     - |
> | SPEC/SPEC2006/INT/400.perlbench/elf               | -7.45%  | 1538352.0000 | 1423800.0000 | - | -7.69%  |     - |
> +---------------------------------------------------+---------+--------------+--------------+---+---------+-------+
> 
> And I really verified on my Haswell machine that sphinx3 changes:
> 
> bloaty new -- old
>      VM SIZE                     FILE SIZE
>  ++++++++++++++ GROWING       ++++++++++++++
>   +0.1%     +24 .eh_frame         +24  +0.1%
>   [ = ]       0 .symtab           +24  +0.2%
>   [ = ]       0 .strtab           +14  +0.2%
>   +0.3%      +8 .eh_frame_hdr      +8  +0.3%
> 
>  -------------- SHRINKING     --------------
>   [ = ]       0 .debug_loc     -164Ki -37.0%
>   [ = ]       0 .debug_line    -118Ki -23.9%
>  -16.7% -35.4Ki .text         -35.4Ki -16.7%
>   [ = ]       0 .debug_ranges -33.1Ki -74.7%
>   [ = ]       0 .debug_info   -31.0Ki  -9.8%
>  -32.0%     -16 [Unmapped]       -679 -16.8%
>   [ = ]       0 .debug_abbrev    -186  -0.5%
> 
>  -11.8% -35.3Ki TOTAL          -382Ki -23.2%
> 
> Martin
> 
> Martin