[Ada] Provide extended contracts for formal doubly linked lists

Arnaud Charlet charlet@adacore.com
Thu Apr 27 09:57:00 GMT 2017


Primitives of doubly linked lists are now annotated with precise
contracts which can be used for formal verification with GNATprove.

Tested on x86_64-pc-linux-gnu, committed on trunk

2017-04-27  Claire Dross  <dross@adacore.com>

	* a-cfdlli.adb, a-cfdlli.ads (=): Generic parameter removed to
	allow the use of regular equality over elements in contracts.
	(Cursor): Type is now public so that it can be used in
	model functions.
	(Formal_Model): Ghost package containing
	model functions that are used in subprogram contracts.
	(Current_To_Last): Removed, model functions should be used
	instead.
	(First_To_Previous): Removed, model functions should
	be used instead.
	(Strict_Equal): Removed, model functions
	should be used instead.
	(Append): Default parameter value
	replaced by new wrapper to allow more precise contracts.
	(Insert): Default parameter value replaced by new wrapper to
	allow more precise contracts.
	(Delete): Default parameter
	value replaced by new wrapper to allow more precise contracts.
	(Prepend): Default parameter value replaced by new wrapper to
	allow more precise contracts.
	(Delete_First): Default parameter
	value replaced by new wrapper to allow more precise contracts.
	(Delete_Last): Default parameter value replaced by new wrapper
	to allow more precise contracts.

-------------- next part --------------
Index: a-cfdlli.adb
===================================================================
--- a-cfdlli.adb	(revision 247293)
+++ a-cfdlli.adb	(working copy)
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
 --                                                                          --
 --                                 B o d y                                  --
 --                                                                          --
---          Copyright (C) 2010-2016, Free Software Foundation, Inc.         --
+--          Copyright (C) 2010-2017, Free Software Foundation, Inc.         --
 --                                                                          --
 -- GNAT is free software;  you can  redistribute it  and/or modify it under --
 -- terms of the  GNU General Public License as published  by the Free Soft- --
@@ -40,10 +40,6 @@
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
       New_Node  : out Count_Type);
 
-   procedure Allocate
-     (Container : in out List;
-      New_Node  : out Count_Type);
-
    procedure Free
      (Container : in out List;
       X         : Count_Type);
@@ -109,31 +105,22 @@
       end if;
    end Allocate;
 
-   procedure Allocate
-     (Container : in out List;
-      New_Node  : out Count_Type)
-   is
-      N : Node_Array renames Container.Nodes;
-
-   begin
-      if Container.Free >= 0 then
-         New_Node := Container.Free;
-         Container.Free := N (New_Node).Next;
-
-      else
-         New_Node := abs Container.Free;
-         Container.Free := Container.Free - 1;
-      end if;
-   end Allocate;
-
    ------------
    -- Append --
    ------------
 
    procedure Append
      (Container : in out List;
+      New_Item  : Element_Type)
+   is
+   begin
+      Insert (Container, No_Element, New_Item, 1);
+   end Append;
+
+   procedure Append
+     (Container : in out List;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    is
    begin
       Insert (Container, No_Element, New_Item, Count);
@@ -161,7 +148,7 @@
 
       J := Source.First;
       while J /= 0 loop
-         Append (Target, N (J).Element);
+         Append (Target, N (J).Element, 1);
          J := N (J).Next;
       end loop;
    end Assign;
@@ -259,44 +246,24 @@
       return P;
    end Copy;
 
-   ---------------------
-   -- Current_To_Last --
-   ---------------------
-
-   function Current_To_Last
-     (Container : List;
-      Current : Cursor) return List is
-      Curs : Cursor := First (Container);
-      C    : List (Container.Capacity) := Copy (Container, Container.Capacity);
-      Node : Count_Type;
-
-   begin
-      if Curs = No_Element then
-         Clear (C);
-         return C;
-      end if;
-
-      if Current /= No_Element and not Has_Element (Container, Current) then
-         raise Constraint_Error;
-      end if;
-
-      while Curs.Node /= Current.Node loop
-         Node := Curs.Node;
-         Delete (C, Curs);
-         Curs := Next (Container, (Node => Node));
-      end loop;
-
-      return C;
-   end Current_To_Last;
-
    ------------
    -- Delete --
    ------------
 
    procedure Delete
      (Container : in out List;
+      Position  : in out Cursor)
+   is
+   begin
+      Delete (Container => Container,
+              Position  => Position,
+              Count     => 1);
+   end Delete;
+
+   procedure Delete
+     (Container : in out List;
       Position  : in out Cursor;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    is
       N : Node_Array renames Container.Nodes;
       X : Count_Type;
@@ -357,9 +324,16 @@
    -- Delete_First --
    ------------------
 
+   procedure Delete_First (Container : in out List)
+   is
+   begin
+      Delete_First (Container => Container,
+                    Count     => 1);
+   end Delete_First;
+
    procedure Delete_First
      (Container : in out List;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    is
       N : Node_Array renames Container.Nodes;
       X : Count_Type;
@@ -391,9 +365,16 @@
    -- Delete_Last --
    -----------------
 
+   procedure Delete_Last (Container : in out List)
+   is
+   begin
+      Delete_Last (Container => Container,
+                   Count     => 1);
+   end Delete_Last;
+
    procedure Delete_Last
      (Container : in out List;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    is
       N : Node_Array renames Container.Nodes;
       X : Count_Type;
@@ -503,36 +484,356 @@
       end if;
    end First_Element;
 
-   -----------------------
-   -- First_To_Previous --
-   -----------------------
+   ------------------
+   -- Formal_Model --
+   ------------------
 
-   function First_To_Previous
-     (Container : List;
-      Current   : Cursor) return List
-   is
-      Curs : Cursor := Current;
-      C    : List (Container.Capacity) := Copy (Container, Container.Capacity);
-      Node : Count_Type;
+   package body Formal_Model is
 
-   begin
-      if Curs = No_Element then
-         return C;
+      ----------------------------
+      -- Lift_Abstraction_Level --
+      ----------------------------
 
-      elsif not Has_Element (Container, Curs) then
-         raise Constraint_Error;
+      procedure Lift_Abstraction_Level (Container : List) is null;
 
-      else
-         while Curs.Node /= 0 loop
-            Node := Curs.Node;
-            Delete (C, Curs);
-            Curs := Next (Container, (Node => Node));
+      -------------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Contains --
+      -------------------------
+
+      function M_Elements_Contains
+        (S   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst : Count_Type;
+         E   : Element_Type)
+         return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         for I in Fst .. Lst loop
+            if Element (S, I) = E then
+               return True;
+            end if;
          end loop;
+         return False;
+      end M_Elements_Contains;
 
-         return C;
-      end if;
-   end First_To_Previous;
+      --------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Cst --
+      --------------------
 
+      function M_Elements_Cst
+        (S   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst : Count_Type;
+         E   : Element_Type)
+         return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         for I in Fst .. Lst loop
+            if Element (S, I) /= E then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+         return True;
+      end M_Elements_Cst;
+
+      ----------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Equal --
+      ----------------------
+
+      function M_Elements_Equal
+        (S1, S2   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst      : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst      : Count_Type)
+         return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         return M_Elements_Shifted (S1, S2, Fst, Lst, 0);
+      end M_Elements_Equal;
+
+      -------------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Reversed --
+      -------------------------
+
+      function M_Elements_Reversed (S1, S2 : M.Sequence) return Boolean is
+         L : constant Count_Type := M.Length (S1);
+      begin
+         if L /= M.Length (S2) then
+            return False;
+         end if;
+
+         for I in 1 .. L loop
+            if Element (S1, I) /= Element (S2, L - I + 1)
+            then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         return True;
+      end M_Elements_Reversed;
+
+      ------------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Shifted --
+      ------------------------
+
+      function M_Elements_Shifted
+        (S1, S2   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst      : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst      : Count_Type;
+         Offset   : Count_Type'Base := 1)
+         return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         for I in Fst .. Lst loop
+            if Element (S1, I) /= Element (S2, I + Offset) then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+         return True;
+      end M_Elements_Shifted;
+
+      -------------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Shuffled --
+      -------------------------
+
+      function M_Elements_Shuffle
+        (S1, S2   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst      : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst      : Count_Type;
+         Offset   : Count_Type'Base)
+         return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         for I in Fst .. Lst loop
+            declare
+               Found : Boolean := False;
+               J     : Count_Type := Fst;
+            begin
+               while not Found and J <= Lst loop
+                  if Element (S1, I) = Element (S2, J + Offset) then
+                     Found := True;
+                  end if;
+                  J := J + 1;
+               end loop;
+
+               if not Found then
+                  return False;
+               end if;
+            end;
+         end loop;
+         return True;
+      end M_Elements_Shuffle;
+
+      ------------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Swapted --
+      ------------------------
+
+      function M_Elements_Swapped
+        (S1, S2 : M.Sequence;
+         X, Y   : Positive_Count_Type)
+      return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         if M.Length (S1) /= M.Length (S2)
+           or else Element (S1, X) /= Element (S2, Y)
+           or else Element (S1, Y) /= Element (S2, X)
+         then
+            return False;
+         end if;
+
+         for I in 1 .. M.Length (S1) loop
+            if I /= X and then I /= Y
+              and then Element (S1, I) /= Element (S2, I)
+            then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         return True;
+      end M_Elements_Swapped;
+
+      -----------
+      -- Model --
+      -----------
+
+      function Model (Container : List) return M.Sequence is
+         Position : Count_Type := Container.First;
+         R        : M.Sequence;
+      begin
+         --  Can't use First, Next or Element here, since they depend
+         --  on models for their postconditions
+         while Position /= 0 loop
+            R := M.Add (R, Container.Nodes (Position).Element);
+            Position := Container.Nodes (Position).Next;
+         end loop;
+         return R;
+      end Model;
+
+      -----------------------
+      -- Mapping_preserved --
+      -----------------------
+
+      function Mapping_Preserved
+        (S1, S2 : M.Sequence;
+         M1, M2 : P.Map) return Boolean is
+
+      begin
+         for C of M1 loop
+            if not P.Mem (M2, C)
+              or else P.Get (M1, C) > M.Length (S1)
+              or else P.Get (M2, C) > M.Length (S2)
+              or else M.Get (S1, P.Get (M1, C)) /= M.Get (S2, P.Get (M2, C))
+            then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         for C of M2 loop
+            if not P.Mem (M1, C) then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         return True;
+      end Mapping_Preserved;
+
+      -------------------------
+      -- P_Positions_Shifted --
+      -------------------------
+
+      function P_Positions_Shifted
+        (Small : P.Map;
+         Big   : P.Map;
+         Cut   : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Count : Count_Type := 1) return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         for Cu of Small loop
+            if not P.Mem (Big, Cu) then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         for Cu of Big loop
+            declare
+               Pos : constant Positive_Count_Type := P.Get (Big, Cu);
+            begin
+               if Pos < Cut then
+                  if not P.Mem (Small, Cu) or else Pos /= P.Get (Small, Cu)
+                  then
+                     return False;
+                  end if;
+               elsif Pos >= Cut + Count then
+                  if not P.Mem (Small, Cu)
+                    or else Pos /= P.Get (Small, Cu) + Count
+                  then
+                     return False;
+                  end if;
+               else
+                  if P.Mem (Small, Cu) then
+                     return False;
+                  end if;
+               end if;
+            end;
+         end loop;
+         return True;
+      end P_Positions_Shifted;
+
+      -------------------------
+      -- P_Positions_Swapped --
+      -------------------------
+
+      function P_Positions_Swapped
+        (M1, M2 : P.Map;
+         C1, C2 : Cursor) return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         if not P.Mem (M1, C1) or not P.Mem (M1, C2)
+           or not P.Mem (M2, C1) or not P.Mem (M2, C2)
+         then
+            return False;
+         end if;
+
+         if P.Get (M1, C1) /= P.Get (M2, C2)
+             or P.Get (M1, C2) /= P.Get (M2, C1)
+         then
+            return False;
+         end if;
+
+         for C of M1 loop
+            if not P.Mem (M2, C) then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         for C of M2 loop
+            if not P.Mem (M1, C)
+              or else (C /= C1 and C /= C2 and P.Get (M1, C) /= P.Get (M2, C))
+            then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         return True;
+      end P_Positions_Swapped;
+
+      ---------------------------
+      -- P_Positions_Truncated --
+      ---------------------------
+
+      function P_Positions_Truncated
+        (Small : P.Map;
+         Big   : P.Map;
+         Cut   : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Count : Count_Type := 1) return Boolean
+      is
+      begin
+         for Cu of Small loop
+            if not P.Mem (Big, Cu) then
+               return False;
+            end if;
+         end loop;
+
+         for Cu of Big loop
+            declare
+               Pos : constant Positive_Count_Type := P.Get (Big, Cu);
+            begin
+               if Pos < Cut then
+                  if not P.Mem (Small, Cu) or else Pos /= P.Get (Small, Cu)
+                  then
+                     return False;
+                  end if;
+               elsif Pos >= Cut + Count then
+                  return False;
+               elsif P.Mem (Small, Cu) then
+                  return False;
+               end if;
+            end;
+         end loop;
+         return True;
+      end P_Positions_Truncated;
+
+      ---------------
+      -- Positions --
+      ---------------
+
+      function Positions (Container : List) return P.Map is
+         Position : Count_Type := Container.First;
+         R        : P.Map;
+         I        : Count_Type := 1;
+      begin
+         --  Can't use First, Next or Element here, since they depend
+         --  on models for their postconditions
+         while Position /= 0 loop
+            R := P.Add (R, (Node => Position), I);
+            pragma Assert (P.Length (R) = I);
+            Position := Container.Nodes (Position).Next;
+            I := I + 1;
+         end loop;
+         return R;
+      end Positions;
+
+   end Formal_Model;
+
    ----------
    -- Free --
    ----------
@@ -602,6 +903,33 @@
          return True;
       end Is_Sorted;
 
+      -----------------------
+      -- M_Elements_Sorted --
+      -----------------------
+
+      function M_Elements_Sorted (S : M.Sequence) return Boolean is
+      begin
+         if M.Length (S) = 0 then
+            return True;
+         end if;
+
+         declare
+            E1 : Element_Type := Element (S, 1);
+         begin
+            for I in 2 .. M.Length (S) loop
+               declare
+                  E2 : constant Element_Type := Element (S, I);
+               begin
+                  if E2 < E1 then
+                     return False;
+                  end if;
+                  E1 := E2;
+               end;
+            end loop;
+         end;
+         return True;
+      end M_Elements_Sorted;
+
       -----------
       -- Merge --
       -----------
@@ -766,7 +1094,7 @@
       Before    : Cursor;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
       Position  : out Cursor;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    is
       J : Count_Type;
 
@@ -798,8 +1126,22 @@
      (Container : in out List;
       Before    : Cursor;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Position  : out Cursor)
    is
+   begin
+      Insert (Container => Container,
+              Before    => Before,
+              New_Item  => New_Item,
+              Position  => Position,
+              Count     => 1);
+   end Insert;
+
+   procedure Insert
+     (Container : in out List;
+      Before    : Cursor;
+      New_Item  : Element_Type;
+      Count     : Count_Type)
+   is
       Position : Cursor;
    begin
       Insert (Container, Before, New_Item, Position, Count);
@@ -808,33 +1150,11 @@
    procedure Insert
      (Container : in out List;
       Before    : Cursor;
-      Position  : out Cursor;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      New_Item  : Element_Type)
    is
-      J : Count_Type;
-
+      Position : Cursor;
    begin
-      if Before.Node /= 0 then
-         pragma Assert (Vet (Container, Before), "bad cursor in Insert");
-      end if;
-
-      if Count = 0 then
-         Position := Before;
-         return;
-      end if;
-
-      if Container.Length > Container.Capacity - Count then
-         raise Constraint_Error with "new length exceeds capacity";
-      end if;
-
-      Allocate (Container, New_Node => J);
-      Insert_Internal (Container, Before.Node, New_Node => J);
-      Position := (Node => J);
-
-      for Index in 2 .. Count loop
-         Allocate (Container, New_Node => J);
-         Insert_Internal (Container, Before.Node, New_Node => J);
-      end loop;
+      Insert (Container, Before, New_Item, Position, 1);
    end Insert;
 
    ---------------------
@@ -1046,8 +1366,16 @@
 
    procedure Prepend
      (Container : in out List;
+      New_Item  : Element_Type)
+   is
+   begin
+      Insert (Container, First (Container), New_Item, 1);
+   end Prepend;
+
+   procedure Prepend
+     (Container : in out List;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    is
    begin
       Insert (Container, First (Container), New_Item, Count);
@@ -1377,29 +1705,6 @@
       pragma Assert (N (Container.Last).Next = 0);
    end Splice;
 
-   ------------------
-   -- Strict_Equal --
-   ------------------
-
-   function Strict_Equal (Left, Right : List) return Boolean is
-      CL : Count_Type := Left.First;
-      CR : Count_Type := Right.First;
-
-   begin
-      while CL /= 0 or CR /= 0 loop
-         if CL /= CR or else
-           Left.Nodes (CL).Element /= Right.Nodes (CL).Element
-         then
-            return False;
-         end if;
-
-         CL := Left.Nodes (CL).Next;
-         CR := Right.Nodes (CR).Next;
-      end loop;
-
-      return True;
-   end Strict_Equal;
-
    ----------
    -- Swap --
    ----------
Index: a-cfdlli.ads
===================================================================
--- a-cfdlli.ads	(revision 247293)
+++ a-cfdlli.ads	(working copy)
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
 --                                                                          --
 --                                 S p e c                                  --
 --                                                                          --
---          Copyright (C) 2004-2015, Free Software Foundation, Inc.         --
+--          Copyright (C) 2004-2017, Free Software Foundation, Inc.         --
 --                                                                          --
 -- This specification is derived from the Ada Reference Manual for use with --
 -- GNAT. The copyright notice above, and the license provisions that follow --
@@ -29,43 +29,14 @@
 -- <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.                                          --
 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
---  This spec is derived from Ada.Containers.Bounded_Doubly_Linked_Lists in the
---  Ada 2012 RM. The modifications are meant to facilitate formal proofs by
---  making it easier to express properties, and by making the specification of
---  this unit compatible with SPARK 2014. Note that the API of this unit may be
---  subject to incompatible changes as SPARK 2014 evolves.
+with Ada.Containers.Functional_Vectors;
+with Ada.Containers.Functional_Maps;
 
---  The modifications are:
-
---    A parameter for the container is added to every function reading the
---    contents of a container: Next, Previous, Query_Element, Has_Element,
---    Iterate, Reverse_Iterate, Element. This change is motivated by the need
---    to have cursors which are valid on different containers (typically a
---    container C and its previous version C'Old) for expressing properties,
---    which is not possible if cursors encapsulate an access to the underlying
---    container.
-
---    There are three new functions:
-
---      function Strict_Equal (Left, Right : List) return Boolean;
---      function First_To_Previous  (Container : List; Current : Cursor)
---         return List;
---      function Current_To_Last (Container : List; Current : Cursor)
---         return List;
-
---    See subprogram specifications that follow for details
-
 generic
    type Element_Type is private;
-
-   with function "=" (Left, Right : Element_Type)
-                      return Boolean is <>;
-
 package Ada.Containers.Formal_Doubly_Linked_Lists with
-  Pure,
   SPARK_Mode
 is
-   pragma Annotate (GNATprove, External_Axiomatization);
    pragma Annotate (CodePeer, Skip_Analysis);
 
    type List (Capacity : Count_Type) is private with
@@ -76,39 +47,334 @@
      Default_Initial_Condition => Is_Empty (List);
    pragma Preelaborable_Initialization (List);
 
-   type Cursor is private;
-   pragma Preelaborable_Initialization (Cursor);
+   type Cursor is record
+      Node : Count_Type := 0;
+   end record;
 
+   No_Element : constant Cursor := Cursor'(Node => 0);
+
    Empty_List : constant List;
 
-   No_Element : constant Cursor;
+   function Length (Container : List) return Count_Type with
+     Global => null,
+     Post   => Length'Result <= Container.Capacity;
 
+   pragma Unevaluated_Use_Of_Old (Allow);
+
+   package Formal_Model with Ghost is
+      subtype Positive_Count_Type is Count_Type range 1 .. Count_Type'Last;
+
+      package M is new Ada.Containers.Functional_Vectors
+        (Index_Type   => Positive_Count_Type,
+         Element_Type => Element_Type);
+      function "=" (Left, Right : M.Sequence) return Boolean renames M."=";
+      function "<" (Left, Right : M.Sequence) return Boolean renames M."<";
+      function "<=" (Left, Right : M.Sequence) return Boolean renames M."<=";
+
+      function M_Elements_Contains
+        (S   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst : Count_Type;
+         E   : Element_Type)
+      return Boolean
+      --  E appears in the slice from Fst to Lst in S
+      with
+        Global => null,
+        Pre    => Lst <= M.Length (S),
+        Post   =>
+          M_Elements_Contains'Result =
+            (for some I in Fst .. Lst => Element (S, I) = E);
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Contains);
+
+      function M_Elements_Cst
+        (S   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst : Count_Type;
+         E   : Element_Type)
+      return Boolean
+      --  Every element of the slice from Fst to Lst in S is E.
+      with
+        Global => null,
+        Pre    => Lst <= M.Length (S),
+        Post   =>
+          M_Elements_Cst'Result =
+            (for all I in Fst .. Lst => Element (S, I) = E);
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Cst);
+
+      function M_Elements_Equal
+        (S1, S2 : M.Sequence;
+         Fst    : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst    : Count_Type)
+      return Boolean
+      --  The slice from Fst to Lst is the same in S1 and S2
+      with
+        Global => null,
+        Pre    => Lst <= M.Length (S1) and Lst <= M.Length (S2),
+        Post   =>
+          M_Elements_Equal'Result =
+            (for all I in Fst .. Lst => Element (S1, I) = Element (S2, I));
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Equal);
+
+      function M_Elements_Shuffle
+        (S1, S2 : M.Sequence;
+         Fst    : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst    : Count_Type;
+         Offset : Count_Type'Base)
+      return Boolean
+      --  The slice from Fst to Lst in S1 contains the same elements than the
+      --  same slide shifted by Offset in S2
+      with
+        Global => null,
+        Pre    =>
+          Lst <= M.Length (S1)
+            and Offset in 1 - Fst .. M.Length (S2) - Lst,
+        Post   =>
+          M_Elements_Shuffle'Result =
+          (for all J in Fst + Offset .. Lst + Offset =>
+             (for some I in Fst .. Lst =>
+                    Element (S1, I) = Element (S2, J)));
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Shuffle);
+
+      function M_Elements_Reversed (S1, S2 : M.Sequence) return Boolean
+      --  S2 is S1 in reverse order
+      with
+        Global => null,
+        Post   =>
+          M_Elements_Reversed'Result =
+              (M.Length (S1) = M.Length (S2)
+               and (for all I in 1 .. M.Length (S1) =>
+                   Element (S1, I) = Element (S2, M.Length (S1) - I + 1))
+               and (for all I in 1 .. M.Length (S1) =>
+                   Element (S2, I) = Element (S1, M.Length (S1) - I + 1)));
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Reversed);
+
+      function M_Elements_Shifted
+        (S1, S2   : M.Sequence;
+         Fst      : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Lst      : Count_Type;
+         Offset   : Count_Type'Base := 1)
+      return Boolean
+      --  The slice from Fst to Lst in S1 has been shifted by Offset in S2.
+      with
+          Global => null,
+        Pre    =>
+          Lst <= M.Length (S1)
+            and Offset in 1 - Fst .. M.Length (S2) - Lst,
+        Post   =>
+          M_Elements_Shifted'Result =
+            ((for all I in Fst .. Lst =>
+                      Element (S1, I) = Element (S2, I + Offset))
+             and (for all I in Fst + Offset .. Lst + Offset =>
+                          Element (S1, I - Offset) = Element (S2, I)));
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Shifted);
+
+      function M_Elements_Swapped
+        (S1, S2 : M.Sequence;
+         X, Y   : Positive_Count_Type)
+      return Boolean
+      --  Elements stored at X and Y are reversed in S1 and S2
+      with
+        Global => null,
+        Pre    => X <= M.Length (S1) and Y <= M.Length (S1),
+        Post   =>
+          M_Elements_Swapped'Result =
+            (M.Length (S1) = M.Length (S2)
+             and Element (S1, X) = Element (S2, Y)
+             and Element (S1, Y) = Element (S2, X)
+             and
+               (for all I in 1 .. M.Length (S1) =>
+                 (if I /= X and I /= Y
+                    then Element (S1, I) = Element (S2, I))));
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Swapped);
+
+      package P is new Ada.Containers.Functional_Maps
+        (Key_Type        => Cursor,
+         Element_Type    => Positive_Count_Type,
+         Equivalent_Keys => "=");
+      function "=" (Left, Right : P.Map) return Boolean renames P."=";
+      function "<=" (Left, Right : P.Map) return Boolean renames P."<=";
+
+      function P_Positions_Shifted
+        (Small : P.Map;
+         Big   : P.Map;
+         Cut   : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Count : Count_Type := 1) return Boolean
+      with
+        Global => null,
+        Post   =>
+          P_Positions_Shifted'Result =
+
+         --  Big contains all cursors of Small
+        ((for all I of Small => P.Mem (Big, I))
+
+         --  Cursors located before Cut are not moved, cursors located after
+         --  are shifted by Count.
+         and
+           (for all I of Small =>
+                  (if P.Get (Small, I) < Cut
+                   then P.Get (Big, I) = P.Get (Small, I)
+                   else P.Get (Big, I) - Count = P.Get (Small, I)))
+
+         --  New cursors of Big (if any) are between Cut and Cut - 1 + Count
+         and
+           (for all I of Big =>
+                 P.Mem (Small, I)
+              or P.Get (Big, I) - Count in Cut - Count  .. Cut - 1));
+
+      function P_Positions_Swapped
+        (M1, M2 : P.Map;
+         C1, C2 : Cursor) return Boolean
+      --  M1 and M2 contain the same cursors, but the positions of C1 and C2
+      --  are reversed.
+      with
+        Ghost,
+        Global => null,
+        Post   =>
+          P_Positions_Swapped'Result =
+              ((for all C of M1 => P.Mem (M2, C))
+               and (for all C of M2 => P.Mem (M1, C))
+               and
+                 (for all C of M1 =>
+                    (if C /= C1 and C /= C2
+                     then P.Get (M1, C) = P.Get (M2, C)))
+               and P.Mem (M1, C1) and P.Mem (M1, C2)
+               and P.Get (M1, C1) = P.Get (M2, C2)
+               and P.Get (M1, C2) = P.Get (M2, C1));
+
+      function P_Positions_Truncated
+        (Small : P.Map;
+         Big   : P.Map;
+         Cut   : Positive_Count_Type;
+         Count : Count_Type := 1) return Boolean
+      with
+        Ghost,
+        Global => null,
+        Post   =>
+          P_Positions_Truncated'Result =
+
+         --  Big contains all cursors of Small
+        ((for all I of Small => P.Mem (Big, I))
+
+         --  The cursors of Small are all bellow Cut
+         and (for all I of Small => P.Get (Small, I) < Cut)
+
+         --  The cursors have the same position in Big and Small
+         and (for all I of Small => P.Get (Big, I) = P.Get (Small, I))
+
+         --  New cursors of Big (if any) are between Cut and Cut - 1 + Count
+         and
+           (for all I of Big =>
+                P.Mem (Small, I)
+             or P.Get (Big, I) - Count in Cut - Count .. Cut - 1));
+
+      function Mapping_Preserved
+        (S1, S2 : M.Sequence;
+         M1, M2 : P.Map) return Boolean
+      with
+        Ghost,
+        Global => null,
+        Post   =>
+            (if Mapping_Preserved'Result then
+
+            --  M1 contains all cursors of M2
+            (for all I of M2 => P.Mem (M1, I))
+
+            --  M2 contains all cursors of M1
+            and (for all I of M1 => P.Mem (M2, I))
+
+            --  Mappings from cursors to elements induced by S1, M1 and S2, M2
+            --  are the same.
+            and (for all I of M1 =>
+                       M.Get (S1, P.Get (M1, I)) = M.Get (S2, P.Get (M2, I))));
+
+      function Model (Container : List) return M.Sequence with
+      --  The highlevel model of a list is a sequence of elements. Cursors are
+      --  not represented in this model.
+
+        Ghost,
+        Global => null,
+        Post   => M.Length (Model'Result) = Length (Container);
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Iterable_For_Proof, "Model", Model);
+
+      function Positions (Container : List) return P.Map with
+      --  The Positions map is used to model cursors. It only contains valid
+      --  cursors and map them to their position in the container.
+
+        Ghost,
+        Global => null,
+        Post   => not P.Mem (Positions'Result, No_Element)
+        --  Positions of cursors are smaller than the container's length.
+        and then
+          (for all I of Positions'Result =>
+             P.Get (Positions'Result, I) in 1 .. Length (Container)
+
+               --  No two cursors have the same position. Note that we do not
+           --  state that there is a cursor in the map for each position,
+           --  as it is rarely needed.
+           and then
+             (for all J of Positions'Result =>
+                (if P.Get (Positions'Result, I) = P.Get (Positions'Result, J)
+                     then I = J)));
+
+      procedure Lift_Abstraction_Level (Container : List) with
+        --  Lift_Abstraction_Level is a ghost procedure that does nothing but
+        --  assume that we can access to the same elements by iterating over
+        --  positions or cursors.
+        --  This information is not generally useful except when switching from
+        --  a lowlevel, cursor aware view of a container, to a highlevel
+        --  position based view.
+
+        Ghost,
+        Global => null,
+        Post   =>
+            (for all Elt of Model (Container) =>
+               (for some I of Positions (Container) =>
+                    M.Get (Model (Container), P.Get (Positions (Container), I))
+                    = Elt));
+
+      function Element (S : M.Sequence; I : Count_Type) return Element_Type
+                     renames M.Get;
+      --  To improve readability of contracts, we rename the function used to
+      --  access an element in the model to Element.
+   end Formal_Model;
+   use Formal_Model;
+
    function "=" (Left, Right : List) return Boolean with
-     Global => null;
+     Global => null,
+     Post   => "="'Result = (Model (Left) = Model (Right));
 
-   function Length (Container : List) return Count_Type with
-     Global => null;
-
    function Is_Empty (Container : List) return Boolean with
-     Global => null;
+     Global => null,
+     Post   => Is_Empty'Result = (Length (Container) = 0);
 
    procedure Clear (Container : in out List) with
-     Global => null;
+     Global => null,
+     Post   => Length (Container) = 0;
 
    procedure Assign (Target : in out List; Source : List) with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Target.Capacity >= Length (Source);
+     Pre    => Target.Capacity >= Length (Source),
+     Post   => Model (Target) = Model (Source);
 
    function Copy (Source : List; Capacity : Count_Type := 0) return List with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Capacity = 0 or else Capacity >= Source.Capacity;
+     Pre    => Capacity = 0 or else Capacity >= Source.Capacity,
+     Post   => Model (Copy'Result) = Model (Source)
+     and Positions (Copy'Result) = Positions (Source)
+     and (if Capacity = 0 then Copy'Result.Capacity = Source.Capacity
+          else Copy'Result.Capacity = Capacity);
 
    function Element
      (Container : List;
       Position : Cursor) return Element_Type
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position);
+     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position),
+     Post   =>
+       Element'Result =
+         Element (Model (Container),
+                  P.Get (Positions (Container), Position));
+   pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, Element);
 
    procedure Replace_Element
      (Container : in out List;
@@ -116,229 +382,1007 @@
       New_Item  : Element_Type)
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position);
+     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position),
+     Post   => Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old
 
+     --  Cursors are preserved.
+     and Positions (Container)'Old = Positions (Container)
+
+     --  The element at the position of Position in Container is replaced by
+     --  New_Item.
+     and M.Is_Set (Model (Container)'Old,
+                   P.Get (Positions (Container), Position),
+                   New_Item,
+                   Model (Container));
+
    procedure Move (Target : in out List; Source : in out List) with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Target.Capacity >= Length (Source);
+     Pre    => Target.Capacity >= Length (Source),
+     Post   => Model (Target) = Model (Source'Old)
+     and Length (Source) = 0;
 
    procedure Insert
      (Container : in out List;
       Before    : Cursor;
+      New_Item  : Element_Type)
+   with
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            =>
+         Length (Container) < Container.Capacity
+       and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
+                 or else Before = No_Element),
+     Post           => Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + 1,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Before = No_Element =>
+
+          --  Positions contains a new mapping from the last cursor of
+          --  Container to its length.
+          P.Is_Add
+            (Positions (Container)'Old, Last (Container), Length (Container),
+             Result => Positions (Container))
+
+          --  Model contains a new element New_Item at the end
+          and M.Is_Add (Model (Container)'Old, New_Item, Model (Container)),
+        others              =>
+
+          --  The elements of Container located before Before are preserved.
+          M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before) - 1)
+
+          --  Other elements are shifted by 1.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before),
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => 1)
+
+          --  New_Item is stored at the previous position of Before in
+          --  Container
+          and Element
+            (Model (Container), P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before))
+               = New_Item
+
+          --  A new cursor has been inserted at position Before in Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before)));
+
+   procedure Insert
+     (Container : in out List;
+      Before    : Cursor;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Length (Container) + Count <= Container.Capacity
-                 and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
-                            or else Before = No_Element);
+       Pre    =>
+         Length (Container) <= Container.Capacity - Count
+       and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
+                 or else Before = No_Element),
+     Post           => Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + Count,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Before = No_Element =>
 
+          --  The elements of Container are preserved
+          M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => Length (Container)'Old)
+
+          --  Container contains Count times New_Item at the end
+          and M_Elements_Cst
+            (S   => Model (Container),
+             Fst => Length (Container)'Old + 1,
+             Lst => Length (Container),
+             E   => New_Item)
+
+          --  A Count cursors have been inserted at the end of Container
+          and P_Positions_Truncated
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut   => Length (Container)'Old + 1,
+             Count => Count),
+        others              =>
+
+          --  The elements of Container located before Before are preserved
+          M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before) - 1)
+
+          --  Other elements are shifted by Count.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before),
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => Count)
+
+          --  Container contains Count times New_Item after position Before
+          and M_Elements_Cst
+            (S   => Model (Container),
+             Fst => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before),
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before) - 1 + Count,
+             E   => New_Item)
+
+          --  Count cursors have been inserted at position Before in Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut   => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before),
+             Count => Count));
+
    procedure Insert
      (Container : in out List;
       Before    : Cursor;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
-      Position  : out Cursor;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Position  : out Cursor)
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Length (Container) + Count <= Container.Capacity
-                 and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
-                            or else Before = No_Element);
+     Pre    =>
+         Length (Container) < Container.Capacity
+       and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
+                 or else Before = No_Element),
+     Post   =>
+       Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + 1
 
+          --  Positions is valid in Container and it is located either before
+          --  Before if it is valid in Container or at the end if it is
+          --  No_Element.
+          and P.Mem (Positions (Container), Position)
+          and (if Before = No_Element
+               then P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)
+                  = Length (Container)
+               else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)
+                  = P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before))
+
+          --  The elements of Container located before Position are preserved.
+          and M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) - 1)
+
+          --  Other elements are shifted by 1.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position),
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => 1)
+
+          --  New_Item is stored at Position in Container
+          and Element
+            (Model (Container), P.Get (Positions (Container), Position))
+               = New_Item
+
+          --  A new cursor has been inserted at position Position in Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position));
+
    procedure Insert
      (Container : in out List;
       Before    : Cursor;
+      New_Item  : Element_Type;
       Position  : out Cursor;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    with
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            =>
+         Length (Container) <= Container.Capacity - Count
+       and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
+                 or else Before = No_Element),
+     Post           => Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + Count,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Count = 0 => Position = Before
+          and Model (Container) = Model (Container)'Old
+          and Positions (Container) = Positions (Container)'Old,
+
+        others    =>
+          --  Positions is valid in Container and it is located either before
+          --  Before if it is valid in Container or at the end if it is
+          --  No_Element.
+          P.Mem (Positions (Container), Position)
+          and (if Before = No_Element
+               then P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)
+                  = Length (Container)'Old + 1
+               else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)
+                  = P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before))
+
+          --  The elements of Container located before Position are preserved.
+          and M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) - 1)
+
+          --  Other elements are shifted by Count.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position),
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => Count)
+
+          --  Container contains Count times New_Item after position Position
+          and M_Elements_Cst
+            (S   => Model (Container),
+             Fst => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position),
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) - 1 + Count,
+             E   => New_Item)
+
+          --  Count cursor have been inserted at Position in Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut   => P.Get (Positions (Container), Position),
+             Count => Count));
+
+   procedure Prepend
+     (Container : in out List;
+      New_Item  : Element_Type)
+   with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Length (Container) + Count <= Container.Capacity
-                 and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
-                            or else Before = No_Element);
+     Pre    => Length (Container) < Container.Capacity,
+     Post   =>
+       Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + 1
 
+          --  Elements are shifted by 1
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => 1)
+
+          --  New_Item is the first element of Container
+          and Element (Model (Container), 1) = New_Item
+
+          --  A new cursor has been inserted at the beginning of Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut => 1);
+
    procedure Prepend
      (Container : in out List;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Length (Container) + Count <= Container.Capacity;
+     Pre    => Length (Container) <= Container.Capacity - Count,
+     Post   =>
+       Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + Count
 
+          --  Elements are shifted by Count.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => Count)
+
+          --  Container starts with Count times New_Item
+          and M_Elements_Cst
+            (S   => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => Count,
+             E   => New_Item)
+
+          --  Count cursors have been inserted at the beginning of Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut   => 1,
+             Count => Count);
+
    procedure Append
      (Container : in out List;
+      New_Item  : Element_Type)
+   with
+     Global => null,
+     Pre    => Length (Container) < Container.Capacity,
+     Post   => Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + 1
+
+          --  Positions contains a new mapping from the last cursor of
+          --  Container to its length.
+          and P.Is_Add
+            (Positions (Container)'Old, Last (Container), Length (Container),
+             Result => Positions (Container))
+
+          --  Model contains a new element New_Item at the end
+          and M.Is_Add (Model (Container)'Old, New_Item, Model (Container));
+
+   procedure Append
+     (Container : in out List;
       New_Item  : Element_Type;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Length (Container) + Count <= Container.Capacity;
+     Pre    => Length (Container) <= Container.Capacity - Count,
+     Post   =>
+       Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old + Count
 
+          --  The elements of Container are preserved
+          and Model (Container)'Old <= Model (Container)
+
+          --  Container contains Count times New_Item at the end
+          and M_Elements_Cst
+            (S   => Model (Container),
+             Fst => Length (Container)'Old + 1,
+             Lst => Length (Container),
+             E   => New_Item)
+
+          --  Count cursors have been inserted at the end of Container
+          and P_Positions_Truncated
+            (Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Positions (Container),
+             Cut   => Length (Container)'Old + 1,
+             Count => Count);
+
    procedure Delete
      (Container : in out List;
+      Position  : in out Cursor)
+   with
+     Global => null,
+     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position),
+     Post   =>
+       Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old - 1
+
+          --  Position is set to No_Element
+          and Position = No_Element
+
+          --  The elements of Container located before Position are preserved.
+          and M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old) - 1)
+
+          --  The elements located after Position are shifted by 1
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old) + 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => -1)
+
+          --  Position has been removed from Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container),
+             Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Cut   => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old));
+
+   procedure Delete
+     (Container : in out List;
       Position  : in out Cursor;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    with
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            => Has_Element (Container, Position),
+     Post           =>
+          Length (Container) in Length (Container)'Old - Count
+                                        .. Length (Container)'Old
+
+          --  Position is set to No_Element
+          and Position = No_Element
+
+          --  The elements of Container located before Position are preserved.
+          and M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old) - 1),
+     Contract_Cases =>
+
+       --  All the elements after Position have been erased
+       (Length (Container) - Count < P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)
+        =>
+
+          Length (Container) =
+            P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old) - 1
+
+          --  At most Count cursors have been removed at the end of Container
+          and P_Positions_Truncated
+            (Positions (Container),
+             Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Cut   => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old),
+             Count => Count),
+        others =>
+          Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old - Count
+
+          --  Other elements are shifted by Count
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    =>
+               P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old) + Count,
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => -Count)
+
+          --  Count cursors have been removed from Container at Position
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container),
+             Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Cut   => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position'Old),
+             Count => Count));
+
+   procedure Delete_First (Container : in out List)
+   with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position);
+     Pre    => not Is_Empty (Container),
+     Post   =>
+       Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old - 1
 
+          --  The elements of Container are shifted by 1
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => 2,
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => -1)
+
+          --  The first cursor of Container has been removed
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container),
+             Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Cut   => 1);
+
    procedure Delete_First
      (Container : in out List;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    with
-     Global => null;
+     Global         => null,
+     Contract_Cases =>
 
+       --  All the elements of Container have been erased
+       (Length (Container) <= Count => Length (Container) = 0,
+        others =>
+          Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old - Count
+
+          --  Elements of Container are shifted by Count
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => Count + 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => -Count)
+
+          --  The first Count cursors have been removed from Container
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Container),
+             Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Cut   => 1,
+             Count => Count));
+
+   procedure Delete_Last (Container : in out List)
+   with
+     Global => null,
+     Pre    => not Is_Empty (Container),
+     Post   =>
+       Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old - 1
+
+          --  The elements of Container are preserved.
+          and Model (Container) <= Model (Container)'Old
+
+          --  The last cursor of Container has been removed
+          and P.Is_Add (Positions (Container), Last (Container)'Old,
+                        Length (Container)'Old, Positions (Container)'Old);
+
    procedure Delete_Last
      (Container : in out List;
-      Count     : Count_Type := 1)
+      Count     : Count_Type)
    with
-     Global => null;
+     Global => null,
+     Contract_Cases =>
 
+       --  All the elements of Container have been erased
+       (Length (Container) <= Count => Length (Container) = 0,
+        others =>
+
+          Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old - Count
+
+          --  The elements of Container are preserved.
+          and Model (Container) <= Model (Container)'Old
+
+          --  At most Count cursors have been removed at the end of Container
+          and P_Positions_Truncated
+            (Positions (Container),
+             Positions (Container)'Old,
+             Cut   => Length (Container) + 1,
+             Count => Count));
+
    procedure Reverse_Elements (Container : in out List) with
-     Global => null;
+     Global => null,
+     Post   => M_Elements_Reversed (Model (Container'Old), Model (Container));
 
    procedure Swap
      (Container : in out List;
       I, J      : Cursor)
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, I) and then Has_Element (Container, J);
+     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, I) and then Has_Element (Container, J),
+     Post   =>
+       M_Elements_Swapped
+         (Model (Container)'Old, Model (Container),
+          X => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, I),
+          Y => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, J))
+       and Positions (Container) = Positions (Container)'Old;
 
    procedure Swap_Links
      (Container : in out List;
       I, J      : Cursor)
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, I) and then Has_Element (Container, J);
+     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, I) and then Has_Element (Container, J),
+     Post   =>
+       M_Elements_Swapped
+         (Model (Container'Old), Model (Container),
+          X => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, I),
+          Y => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, J))
+       and P_Positions_Swapped
+       (Positions (Container)'Old, Positions (Container), I, J);
 
    procedure Splice
      (Target : in out List;
       Before : Cursor;
       Source : in out List)
+   --  Target and Source should not be aliased
    with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Length (Source) + Length (Target) <= Target.Capacity
-                 and then (Has_Element (Target, Before)
-                            or else Before = No_Element);
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            =>
+         Length (Source) <= Target.Capacity - Length (Target)
+         and then (Has_Element (Target, Before)
+                   or else Before = No_Element),
+     Post           =>
+       Length (Source) = 0
+           and Length (Target) = Length (Target)'Old + Length (Source)'Old,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Before = No_Element =>
 
+          --  The elements of Target are preserved
+          M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Target)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Target),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => Length (Target)'Old)
+
+          --  The elements of Source are appended to target, the order is not
+          --  specified.
+          and M_Elements_Shuffle
+            (S1     => Model (Source)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Target),
+             Fst    => 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Source)'Old,
+             Offset => Length (Target)'Old)
+
+          --  Cursors have been inserted at the end of Target
+          and P_Positions_Truncated
+            (Positions (Target)'Old,
+             Positions (Target),
+             Cut   => Length (Target)'Old + 1,
+             Count => Length (Source)'Old),
+        others              =>
+
+          --  The elements of Target located before Before are preserved
+          M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Target)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Target),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Target)'Old, Before) - 1)
+
+          --  The elements of Source are inserted before Before, the order is
+          --  not specified.
+          and M_Elements_Shuffle
+            (S1     => Model (Source)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Target),
+             Fst    => 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Source)'Old,
+             Offset => P.Get (Positions (Target)'Old, Before) - 1)
+
+          --  Other elements are shifted by the length of Source
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Target)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Target),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Target)'Old, Before),
+             Lst    => Length (Target)'Old,
+             Offset => Length (Source)'Old)
+
+          --  Cursors have been inserted at position Before in Target
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Target)'Old,
+             Positions (Target),
+             Cut   => P.Get (Positions (Target)'Old, Before),
+             Count => Length (Source)'Old));
+
    procedure Splice
      (Target   : in out List;
       Before   : Cursor;
       Source   : in out List;
       Position : in out Cursor)
+   --  Target and Source should not be aliased
    with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => Length (Source) + Length (Target) <= Target.Capacity
-                 and then (Has_Element (Target, Before)
-                            or else Before = No_Element)
-                 and then Has_Element (Source, Position);
+     Pre    =>
+         (Has_Element (Target, Before)
+          or else Before = No_Element)
+          and then Has_Element (Source, Position)
+          and then Length (Target) < Target.Capacity,
+     Post   =>
+          Length (Target) = Length (Target)'Old + 1
+          and Length (Source) = Length (Source)'Old - 1
 
+          --  The elements of Source located before Position are preserved.
+          and M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Source)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Source),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Source)'Old, Position'Old) - 1)
+
+          --  The elements located after Position are shifted by 1
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Source)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Source),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Source)'Old, Position'Old) + 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Source)'Old,
+             Offset => -1)
+
+          --  Position has been removed from Source
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Source),
+             Positions (Source)'Old,
+             Cut   => P.Get (Positions (Source)'Old, Position'Old))
+
+          --  Positions is valid in Target and it is located either before
+          --  Before if it is valid in Target or at the end if it is
+          --  No_Element.
+          and P.Mem (Positions (Target), Position)
+          and (if Before = No_Element
+               then P.Get (Positions (Target), Position)
+                  = Length (Target)
+               else P.Get (Positions (Target), Position)
+                  = P.Get (Positions (Target)'Old, Before))
+
+          --  The elements of Target located before Position are preserved.
+          and M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Target)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Target),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Target), Position) - 1)
+
+          --  Other elements are shifted by 1.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Target)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Target),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Target), Position),
+             Lst    => Length (Target)'Old,
+             Offset => 1)
+
+          --  The element located at Position in Source is moved to Target
+          and Element (Model (Target), P.Get (Positions (Target), Position))
+            = Element (Model (Source)'Old,
+                       P.Get (Positions (Source)'Old, Position'Old))
+
+          --  A new cursor has been inserted at position Position in Target
+          and P_Positions_Shifted
+            (Positions (Target)'Old,
+             Positions (Target),
+             Cut => P.Get (Positions (Target), Position));
+
    procedure Splice
      (Container : in out List;
       Before    : Cursor;
       Position  : Cursor)
    with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => 2 * Length (Container) <= Container.Capacity
-                 and then (Has_Element (Container, Before)
-                            or else Before = No_Element)
-                 and then Has_Element (Container, Position);
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            =>
+         (Has_Element (Container, Before) or else Before = No_Element)
+         and then Has_Element (Container, Position),
+     Post           => Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Before = Position   =>
+          Model (Container) = Model (Container)'Old
+        and Positions (Container) = Positions (Container)'Old,
 
+        Before = No_Element =>
+
+          --  The elements located before Position are preserved
+          M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position) - 1)
+
+          --  The elements located after Position are shifted by 1
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position) + 1,
+             Lst    => Length (Container)'Old,
+             Offset => -1)
+
+          --  The last element of Container is the one that was previously
+          --  at Position.
+          and Element (Model (Container), Length (Container))
+            = Element (Model (Container)'Old,
+                       P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position))
+
+          --  Cursors from Container continue designating the same elements
+          and Mapping_Preserved
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             M1     => Positions (Container)'Old,
+             M2     => Positions (Container)),
+
+        others              =>
+
+          --  The elements located before Position and Before are preserved
+          M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => 1,
+             Lst => Count_Type'Min
+                      (P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position) - 1,
+                       P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before) - 1))
+
+          --  The elements located after Position and Before are preserved
+          and M_Elements_Equal
+            (S1  => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2  => Model (Container),
+             Fst => Count_Type'Max
+                      (P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position) + 1,
+                       P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before) + 1),
+             Lst => Length (Container))
+
+          --  The elements located after Before and before Position are shifted
+          --  by 1 to the right.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before) + 1,
+             Lst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position) - 1,
+             Offset => 1)
+
+          --  The elements located after Position and before Before are shifted
+          --  by 1 to the left.
+          and M_Elements_Shifted
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             Fst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position) + 1,
+             Lst    => P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before) - 1,
+             Offset => -1)
+
+          --  The element previously at Position is now before Before
+          and Element (Model (Container),
+                       P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Before))
+            = Element (Model (Container)'Old,
+                       P.Get (Positions (Container)'Old, Position))
+
+          --  Cursors from Container continue designating the same elements
+          and Mapping_Preserved
+            (S1     => Model (Container)'Old,
+             S2     => Model (Container),
+             M1     => Positions (Container)'Old,
+             M2     => Positions (Container)));
+
    function First (Container : List) return Cursor with
-     Global => null;
+     Global         => null,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Length (Container) = 0 => First'Result = No_Element,
+        others            => Has_Element (Container, First'Result)
+        and  P.Get (Positions (Container), First'Result) = 1);
 
    function First_Element (Container : List) return Element_Type with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => not Is_Empty (Container);
+     Pre    => not Is_Empty (Container),
+     Post   => First_Element'Result = M.Get (Model (Container), 1);
 
    function Last (Container : List) return Cursor with
-     Global => null;
+     Global         => null,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Length (Container) = 0 => Last'Result = No_Element,
+        others            => Has_Element (Container, Last'Result)
+        and P.Get (Positions (Container), Last'Result) = Length (Container));
 
    function Last_Element (Container : List) return Element_Type with
      Global => null,
-     Pre    => not Is_Empty (Container);
+     Pre    => not Is_Empty (Container),
+     Post   => Last_Element'Result
+             = M.Get (Model (Container), Length (Container));
 
    function Next (Container : List; Position : Cursor) return Cursor with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element;
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            => Has_Element (Container, Position)
+        or else Position = No_Element,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Position = No_Element
+        or else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) = Length (Container) =>
+              Next'Result = No_Element,
+        others => Has_Element (Container, Next'Result)
+        and then P.Get (Positions (Container), Next'Result) =
+          P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) + 1);
 
    procedure Next (Container : List; Position : in out Cursor) with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element;
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            => Has_Element (Container, Position)
+        or else Position = No_Element,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Position = No_Element
+        or else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) = Length (Container) =>
+              Position = No_Element,
+        others => Has_Element (Container, Position)
+        and then P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) =
+          P.Get (Positions (Container), Position'Old) + 1);
 
    function Previous (Container : List; Position : Cursor) return Cursor with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element;
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            => Has_Element (Container, Position)
+        or else Position = No_Element,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Position = No_Element
+        or else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) = 1 =>
+          Previous'Result = No_Element,
+        others =>
+          Has_Element (Container, Previous'Result)
+        and then P.Get (Positions (Container), Previous'Result) =
+          P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) - 1);
 
    procedure Previous (Container : List; Position : in out Cursor) with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element;
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            => Has_Element (Container, Position)
+        or else Position = No_Element,
+     Contract_Cases =>
+       (Position = No_Element
+        or else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) = 1 =>
+          Position = No_Element,
+        others =>
+          Has_Element (Container, Position)
+        and then P.Get (Positions (Container), Position) =
+          P.Get (Positions (Container), Position'Old) - 1);
 
    function Find
      (Container : List;
       Item      : Element_Type;
       Position  : Cursor := No_Element) return Cursor
    with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element;
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            =>
+         Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element,
+     Contract_Cases =>
 
+       --  If Item is not is not contained in Container after Position, Find
+       --  returns No_Element.
+       (not M_Elements_Contains
+          (S   => Model (Container),
+           Fst => (if Position = No_Element then 1
+                   else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)),
+           Lst => Length (Container),
+           E   => Item)
+        =>
+          Find'Result = No_Element,
+
+        --  Otherwise, Find returns a valid cusror in Container
+        others =>
+          P.Mem (Positions (Container), Find'Result)
+
+        --  The element designated by the result of Find is Item
+        and Element (Model (Container),
+                     P.Get (Positions (Container), Find'Result)) = Item
+
+        --  The result of Find is located after Position
+        and (if Position /= No_Element
+             then P.Get (Positions (Container), Find'Result)
+               >= P.Get (Positions (Container), Position))
+
+        --  It is the first occurence of Item in this slice
+        and not M_Elements_Contains
+          (S   => Model (Container),
+           Fst => (if Position = No_Element then 1
+                   else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)),
+           Lst => P.Get (Positions (Container), Find'Result) - 1,
+           E   => Item));
+
    function Reverse_Find
      (Container : List;
       Item      : Element_Type;
       Position  : Cursor := No_Element) return Cursor
    with
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element;
+     Global         => null,
+     Pre            =>
+         Has_Element (Container, Position) or else Position = No_Element,
+     Contract_Cases =>
 
+       --  If Item is not is not contained in Container before Position, Find
+       --  returns No_Element.
+       (not M_Elements_Contains
+          (S   => Model (Container),
+           Fst => 1,
+           Lst => (if Position = No_Element then Length (Container)
+                   else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)),
+           E   => Item)
+        =>
+          Reverse_Find'Result = No_Element,
+
+        --  Otherwise, Find returns a valid cusror in Container
+        others =>
+          P.Mem (Positions (Container), Reverse_Find'Result)
+
+        --  The element designated by the result of Find is Item
+        and Element (Model (Container),
+                     P.Get (Positions (Container), Reverse_Find'Result)) = Item
+
+        --  The result of Find is located before Position
+        and (if Position /= No_Element
+             then P.Get (Positions (Container), Reverse_Find'Result)
+               <= P.Get (Positions (Container), Position))
+
+        --  It is the last occurence of Item in this slice
+        and not M_Elements_Contains
+          (S   => Model (Container),
+           Fst => P.Get (Positions (Container), Reverse_Find'Result) + 1,
+           Lst => (if Position = No_Element then Length (Container)
+                   else P.Get (Positions (Container), Position)),
+           E   => Item));
+
    function Contains
      (Container : List;
       Item      : Element_Type) return Boolean
    with
-     Global => null;
+     Global => null,
+     Post   => Contains'Result =
+         M_Elements_Contains
+          (S   => Model (Container),
+           Fst => 1,
+           Lst => Length (Container),
+           E   => Item);
 
    function Has_Element (Container : List; Position : Cursor) return Boolean
    with
-     Global => null;
+     Global => null,
+     Post   => Has_Element'Result = P.Mem (Positions (Container), Position);
+   pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, Has_Element);
 
    generic
       with function "<" (Left, Right : Element_Type) return Boolean is <>;
    package Generic_Sorting with SPARK_Mode is
+      function M_Elements_Sorted (S : M.Sequence) return Boolean with
+        Ghost,
+        Global => null,
+        Post   => M_Elements_Sorted'Result =
+          (for all I in 1 .. M.Length (S) =>
+             (for all J in I + 1 .. M.Length (S) =>
+                  Element (S, I) = Element (S, J)
+               or Element (S, I) < Element (S, J)));
+      pragma Annotate (GNATprove, Inline_For_Proof, M_Elements_Sorted);
 
       function Is_Sorted (Container : List) return Boolean with
-        Global => null;
+        Global => null,
+        Post   => Is_Sorted'Result = M_Elements_Sorted (Model (Container));
 
       procedure Sort (Container : in out List) with
-        Global => null;
+        Global => null,
+        Post   => Length (Container) = Length (Container)'Old
+        and M_Elements_Sorted (Model (Container));
 
       procedure Merge (Target, Source : in out List) with
-        Global => null;
-
+      --  Target and Source should not be aliased
+        Global => null,
+        Pre    => Length (Source) <= Target.Capacity - Length (Target),
+        Post   => Length (Target) = Length (Target)'Old + Length (Source)'Old
+        and Length (Source) = 0
+        and (if M_Elements_Sorted (Model (Target)'Old)
+               and M_Elements_Sorted (Model (Source)'Old)
+             then M_Elements_Sorted (Model (Target)));
    end Generic_Sorting;
 
-   function Strict_Equal (Left, Right : List) return Boolean with
-     Ghost,
-     Global => null;
-   --  Strict_Equal returns True if the containers are physically equal, i.e.
-   --  they are structurally equal (function "=" returns True) and that they
-   --  have the same set of cursors.
-
-   function First_To_Previous (Container : List; Current : Cursor) return List
-   with
-     Ghost,
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Current) or else Current = No_Element;
-
-   function Current_To_Last (Container : List; Current : Cursor) return List
-   with
-     Ghost,
-     Global => null,
-     Pre    => Has_Element (Container, Current) or else Current = No_Element;
-   --  First_To_Previous returns a container containing all elements preceding
-   --  Current (excluded) in Container. Current_To_Last returns a container
-   --  containing all elements following Current (included) in Container.
-   --  These two new functions can be used to express invariant properties in
-   --  loops which iterate over containers. First_To_Previous returns the part
-   --  of the container already scanned and Current_To_Last the part not
-   --  scanned yet.
-
 private
    pragma SPARK_Mode (Off);
 
@@ -361,12 +1405,6 @@
       Nodes  : Node_Array (1 .. Capacity) := (others => <>);
    end record;
 
-   type Cursor is record
-      Node : Count_Type := 0;
-   end record;
-
    Empty_List : constant List := (0, others => <>);
 
-   No_Element : constant Cursor := (Node => 0);
-
 end Ada.Containers.Formal_Doubly_Linked_Lists;


More information about the Gcc-patches mailing list