[Bug c++/28687] [4.2 regression] dynamic_cast<void*> disallowed too rigorously with -fno-rtti

pkasting at google dot com gcc-bugzilla@gcc.gnu.org
Tue Aug 22 20:31:00 GMT 2006

------- Comment #16 from pkasting at google dot com  2006-08-22 20:31 -------
Comment 4 seems to make it clear that GCC's current behavior differs from past
behavior that was legal under the spec.  I fail to see the utility of the
current behavior or why it would be objectionable to apply the patch on this

(In reply to comment #12)
> | I'm not claiming that the behavior isn't conformant to the docs, I'm claiming
> | that you regressed a construct
> No, we did not regress because the documentation was very explicit.

The documentation was previously incorrect.  The compiler was changed to match
the documentation's behavior, rather than the documentation being changed to
match the compiler's behavior and the C++ standard.  The patch on this bug
makes the IMO correct fix of keeping the compiler behavior and documentation in
sync, but making them match the old, standards-compliant behavior that existing
products rely on.

This bug should be REOPENED.



More information about the Gcc-bugs mailing list