c++/2708: ambiguity check fails for namespace vs class scope

jungman@lanl.gov jungman@lanl.gov
Tue May 1 13:16:00 GMT 2001


>Number:         2708
>Category:       c++
>Synopsis:       ambiguity check fails for namespace vs class scope
>Confidential:   no
>Severity:       serious
>Priority:       low
>Responsible:    unassigned
>State:          open
>Class:          accepts-illegal
>Submitter-Id:   net
>Arrival-Date:   Tue May 01 13:16:01 PDT 2001
>Closed-Date:
>Last-Modified:
>Originator:     jungman@lanl.gov
>Release:        gcc version 2.96 20000731 (Red Hat Linux 7.0)
>Organization:
>Environment:
Reading specs from /usr/lib/gcc-lib/i386-redhat-linux/2.96/specs
>Description:
g++ silently accepts ambiguous declaration with
clash between namespace and class scope. Always
chooses class scope; should probably at least
generate a warning.
>How-To-Repeat:
bellerophon|grp[1642] c++ -g -Wall -save-temps ambiguous.cc
bellerophon|grp[1643] ./a.out 
6
>Fix:
avoid ambiguously scoped declarations
>Release-Note:
>Audit-Trail:
>Unformatted:
----gnatsweb-attachment----
Content-Type: application/x-tar; name="ambiguous.tar"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="ambiguous.tar"
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More information about the Gcc-bugs mailing list