This is the mail archive of the
mailing list for the GCC project.
Re: PATCH: New hook for custom-mangling of C++ scalars
On 21 Mar, 2004, at 19.33, Gabriel Dos Reis wrote:
Ziemowit Laski <email@example.com> writes:
| > | Anyhoo, I'll incorporate your prose (most of which I agree with)
| > | the next version of my patch, and we can iterate from there.
| > |
| > | (Come to think of it, we should do something about the
| > _pretty-printing_
| > | of these types. Currently, error messages refer to nonsensical
| > things
| > | like '__bool int __vector__' and '__bool short __vector__'. I'll
| > whip
| > | up a separate patch.)
| > What do you think would make sense? I'm asking because I'm working
| > currently in that area.
| '__vector', followed by the element type (e.g., '__vector __bool
| '__vector __bool short'); at least this is what AltiVec requires. If
| other targets (e.g., MMX) require other human-readable forms, then we
| would need another hook.
With the big caveat that I'm not an English native speaker, I've
however come across expressions like "Int list", "Float list"
(e.g. particularly in the Standard ML and derived communities), so I
would think that "int __vector__" sounds English as well.
A reason I'm not fan of "__vector int" is that it is easily mistaken
for "vector<int>" which is a different beast.
I'm not a native speaker, either :-); fortunately, we are dealing
with C/C++ and _not_ English. :-) Not to mention the fact that
the human-readable form I propose is consistent with how AltiVec
types are actually written by users.
So, do you think I should add a target hook here? What do others think?
(Note too, that the C standard seems to establish the coding style
covention of "T _Complex". In C++ however, it would be "_Complex T".
I don't think that trying to squeeze AltiVec (or any other _existing_
vendor extension, for that matter) into a language standard is
a worthwhile endeavor. :-) AltiVec is what it is, whatever its
Ziemowit Laski 1 Infinite Loop, MS 301-2K
Mac OS X Compiler Group Cupertino, CA USA 95014-2083
Apple Computer, Inc. +1.408.974.6229 Fax .5477