This is the mail archive of the
java@gcc.gnu.org
mailing list for the Java project.
micro-libgcj merge reconsidered
- From: Joel Dice <dicej at mailsnare dot net>
- To: java at gcc dot gnu dot org
- Date: Mon, 16 Jan 2006 13:08:23 -0700 (MST)
- Subject: micro-libgcj merge reconsidered
Hi all.
Thanks to everyone who contributed to the discussion following my proposal
last Friday.
Reading through that discussion, I found that there are two major
concerns. The first is that micro-libgcj does not adhere to any existing
standard, nor does it provide any well-defined criteria to determine what
features it should or shouldn't have. It has a guiding principle
("smaller is better"), but everyone has his or her own idea of how that is
best achieved.
The second concern is that the cost of maintaining the Java source files
will be high whether we maintain them seperately from the J2SE-targeted
classpath or maintain a unified tree with preprocessing.
In light of both of these concerns, I think the advice of Steph
Meslin-Weber and others is most appropriate - create a branch for
micro-libgcj as proposed, but without intending to merge it into the
trunk. Others may then use that branch as a basis for their own branches
and take them in whatever directions they care to. Elements from any of
these branches may then be merged back into the trunk if and when there is
demand for them.
How does that sound?
- Joel