gcc 2.95.2 has problems with packing and alignment on AIX 4.3(reformatted)

["Jeffrey Dickens" <jdickens at ersi dot com>]

I have retested on the latest compiler and simplified my example program in the hope 
of getting some kind soul to help confirm or deny that there is a problem.

A good first step would be to try it on another platform.  It's a very short program, 
attached.

In the following example, "lc" is  a struct containing a long and a char, "cl" is a struct 
containing a char and a long, "cd" is a struct containing a char and a double, and 
"dc" is a struct containing a double and a char.

The example program just does a sizeof() on each of these 4 variables, as well as 
on an "__attributes__ ((packed))" version of the same.  Here's how it looks 
on one system we have running Gcc 2.8.1:

lc size 8
lc_packed size 5
cl size 8
cl_packed size 5
dc size 12
dc_packed size 9
cd size 12
cd_packed size 9

Now here's how it looks with Gcc 2.95.2 on AIX 4.3:

lc size 8
lc_packed size 5
cl size 8
cl_packed size 5
dc size 16
dc_packed size 16
cd size 12
cd_packed size 9

One would think that the size of "dc" should equal that of "cd" and that 
the size of "dc_packed" should equal that of "cd_packed".  It doesn't.

The real problem for us is that we believe the size of "dc_packed" 
should be 9.  In fact our code was depending on it.  Is this a bad assumption, 
and if so, exactly why ?

Here's the source code:

#include <stdio.h>

struct _cl
{
        char    c;
        long    l;
};


struct _lc
{
        long    l;
        char    c;
};


struct _cd
{
        char    c;
        double  d;
};


struct _dc
{
        double  d;
        char    c;
};


struct _cl_packed
{
        char    c_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
        long    l_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
};


struct _lc_packed
{
        long    l_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
        char    c_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
};


struct _cd_packed
{
        char    c_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
        double  d_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
};


struct _dc_packed
{
        double  d_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
        char    c_packed        __attribute__ ((packed));
};


struct _lc lc;
struct _lc_packed lc_packed;

struct _cl cl;
struct _cl_packed cl_packed;

struct _dc dc;
struct _dc_packed dc_packed;

struct _cd cd;
struct _cd_packed cd_packed;

int main (int argc, char* argv[])
{

        printf ("lc size %d\n", sizeof(lc));
        printf ("lc_packed size %d\n", sizeof(lc_packed));

        printf ("cl size %d\n", sizeof(cl));
        printf ("cl_packed size %d\n", sizeof(cl_packed));

        printf ("dc size %d\n", sizeof(dc));
        printf ("dc_packed size %d\n", sizeof(dc_packed));

        printf ("cd size %d\n", sizeof(cd));
        printf ("cd_packed size %d\n", sizeof(cd_packed));

        exit (0);
}



Jeff Dickens
Software Tools Engineer
ERS Boxborough (978) 264-2832


Jeff Dickens
Software Tools Engineer
ERS Boxborough (978) 264-2832