Re: Question about DRAP register and reserving hard registers

[Richard Henderson <rth at redhat dot com>]

On 06/22/2015 11:14 PM, Steve Ellcey wrote:
> On Fri, 2015-06-19 at 09:09 -0400, Richard Henderson wrote:
> > On 06/16/2015 07:05 PM, Steve Ellcey  wrote:
> > > I have a question about the DRAP register (used for dynamic stack alignment)
> > > and about reserving/using hard registers in general.  I am trying to understand
> > > where, if a drap register is allocated, GCC is told not to use it during
> > > general register allocation.  There must be some code somewhere for this
> > > but I cannot find it.
> >
> > There isn't.  Because the vDRAP register is a pseudo.  The DRAP register is
> > only live from somewhere in the middle of the prologue to the end of the prologue.
> >
> > See ix86_get_drap_rtx, wherein we coordinate with the to-be-generated prologue
> > (crtl->drap_reg), allocate the pseudo, and emit the hard-reg-to-pseudo copy at
> > entry_of_function.
> >
> >
> > r~
>
> OK, I think I have this part of the code working on MIPS but
> crtl->drap_reg is used in the epilogue as well as the prologue even if
> it is not 'live' in between.  If I understand the code correctly the x86
> prologue pushes the drap register on to the stack so that the epilogue
> can pop it off and use it to restore the stack pointer.  Is my
> understanding correct?

Yes.  Although that saved copy is also used by unwind info.


> I also need the drap pointer in the MIPS epilogue but I would like to
> avoid having to get it from memory.  Ideally I would like to restore it
> from the virtual register that the prologue code / get_drap_rtx code put
> it into.  I tried just doing a move from the virtual drap register to
> the real one in expand_epilogue but that didn't work because it looks
> like you can't access virtual registers from expand_prologue or
> expand_epilogue.  I guess that is why the code to copy the hard drap reg
> to the virtual drap_reg is done in get_drap_reg and not in
> expand_prologue.  I thought about putting code in get_drap_reg to do
> this copying but I don't see how to access the end of a function.  The
> hard drap reg to virtual drap reg copy is inserted into the beginning of
> a function with:
>
> insn = emit_insn_before (seq, NEXT_INSN (entry_of_function ()));
>
> Is there an equivalent method to insert code to the end of a function?
> I don't see an 'end_of_function ()' routine anywhere.

Because, while generating initial rtl for a function, the beginning of a 
function has already been emitted, while the end of the function hasn't.

You'd need to hook into expand_function_end, right at the bottom, before the 
call to use_return_register.


r~